The Congeniality trophy was renamed the Sheila Kleiman Congeniality Trophy in 2006.

2018–Linda MacCleave
2017–Ed Kinlaw
2016–Francis Terminella

2015–Anne and Harry Alferink

2014–Winnie Fratkin

2013–Ruth Miles

2012–Richard Hagenlocker

2011–Sue Sims

2010–Michael & Ellen Hartenberg and Erna Gale White

2009–Margaret Anderson

2008–Steve Chaplin

2007–Paul Anderson

2006–Betty Loving

2005–Dale Hankins

2004–Will Williams & Jack Buchanan

2003–Jerry Dellinger

2002–Bev Spooner

2001–Joyce Angelini

2000–Elvia Lewis

1999–Debra Willis

1998–Ann Rae Gershman and Phil Calvo

1997–Bobby Pustilnik

1996–Betty Griffin

1995–Nadine Griffin

1994–Ruth Short

1993–Genevieve Simms

1992–Sheila Kleiman

1991–Bea Goldberg

1990–Ruth Noblin

1989–Tee Kibler

1988–Virginia Penesi

1987–Martha Graham

1986–Jane Daniel

1984–George Euksuzian

1983–Irene Klinchock

1982–Margaret Fraley

1981–Stanley Ford

1980–Nene Fleming

1979–Bob Alltop

1978–Edward Harlow

1977–Mrs. J. V. Reidelbach

1976–Dr. Thomas Chalkley

1975–William Lumpkin, Jr.

1974–Larry Thompson

1973–Archie Straus

1972–Nora Attack